How to Eliminate Chatter
Eliminating chatter is a great way to improve surface finish when performing CNC milling. Control technology detects chatter and automatically adjusts spindle speed to eliminate chatter, thus improving surface finish.
Surface finish problems can be profit killers for today’s mold manufacturer. One of the most common causes is chatter created by vibration in the CNC machine tool cutting process. This can lead to higher costs, delayed deliveries and even lost orders due to poor quality. In addition, vibration can cause uneven tool wear, resulting in poor surface finish, geometry inconsistencies and reduced tool life.
Chatter is caused by the inherent natural frequency of the cutting tool. It can be triggered by many process conditions: toolholding, cutter tooling, part fixturing and machine conditions. Typically operators try to combat chatter by combining multiple solutions, but some of these may be impossible to implement due to part geometries or machine limitations. Fortunately, there is new technology available today that can eliminate chatter from your cutting processes.
Following are some of the techniques commonly used to combat chatter. Use these guidelines to establish a good foundation for optimizing your moldmaking processes.
1. The Right Toolholder: Common toolholders (side-lock, double-angle collets and standard ER collets) do not provide the accuracy or stiffness needed for high-performance machining. Better options are toolholder shanks that incorporate face and taper contact to deliver high accuracy and rigidity. This type of holder engages the precision ground face of the spindle with simultaneous contact with the taper, which provides the additional rigidity required, and also aids in damping. All tooling should be evaluated for balancing, which provides improvements in surface finish even at lower RPMs.
2. Cutter Tooling Selection: Cutter tooling can greatly influence chatter. Considerations include correct substrate, geometry, coating and length-diameter ratio. Programmers often gravitate to using the largest tool that can fit, but that may not be the ideal tool size. Incorporating multiple tools with variable flute geometries is an effective way to reduce vibrations.
3. Proper Workholding: If the part is not properly secured, the part itself can vibrate and induce chatter. There are many excellent systems available to clamp your workpieces. Criteria to look for include high precision, high clamping force, ease of use and flexibility (allowing use across multiple CNC machine tool platforms).
4. Machine Maintenance: If you’re trying to hold fine finishes and tight tolerances on a poorly maintained machine, you’ll need to overcome mechanical challenges well beyond the issues listed here. Keep your equipment on a regular maintenance schedule to ensure the best performance.
5. Control Solution: The above can correct some causes of chatter, but there are limitations to these methods. The use of new control technology—smart control systems—that navigates processes and eliminates potentials for costly surface finish problems is another method. One such technology1 is designed to eliminate chatter and take the guesswork out of the trial-and-error process typically used to find the correct spindle speed, allowing the cutting tool and machine tool to continuously operate at the highest performance. It uses a single processor intelligent numerical control2 and vibration sensors to monitor chatter noise and automatically adjust spindle speed. No longer does an operator need to babysit a cut. With this technology in place, your mold shop can be more profitable and gain a competitive advantage.
1 Okuma’s Intelligent Technologies is Machining Navi M-i.
2 Okuma OSP THINC control
Mold performance and durability depends on mold base quality, and hole making is a crucial step in the process.
The alternative you choose to achieve five-axis machining benefits will be application driven and can have a significant effect on your bottom line.
With moldmaking the focus is on injection molding or other mold types that use wire EDM or CNC machining centers to create the mold components. Your typical machining center weighs several tons and has a relatively small working envelope compared to a CNC router. The mill’s massive construction lends itself to machining rigid materials with very tight tolerances. While this type of CNC is suited for injection molding components, it isn’t always the ideal tool for the job when we broaden our scope of moldmaking and the current opportunities in the marketplace