Three Takeaways from Die/Mold Expo
What do you gain by attending events like the Makino Die/Mold Expo that was held last week at the company’s Technology Center in Auburn Hills, Michigan? I asked a few of the moldmakers I met there to share their personal takeaways.
There is always an opportunity to learn and see and share when attending events like the Makino Die/Mold Expo in Auburn Hills, Michigan. I asked a few moldmakers I met there to share their personal takeaways from the event and here’s what they told me:
Don Snow, president of CS Tool Engineering in Cedar Springs, Michigan, says, “I was impressed with the surface finishes on the test cavity (for the center console of an automobile) that was machined on the new five-axis V80S that Makino introduced.” Snow says the workpiece (pictured above) showed virtually no machining marks, even in the very tight areas of the cavity, and he notes that it was a good thing that the V80S produced such a fine surface finish because a polisher could cut himself on the razor-sharp outer edges. Makino unveiled the V80S at the Expo, calling it its “next-gen vertical machining center for true, five-axis continuous processing.” According to Makino, the high-precision VMC evolved from the company’s three-axis Vi series and boasts an updated spindle and titling/rotating axis unit that supports tighter tolerances and decreased machining and polishing times. The V80S can accommodate workpiece sizes up to 1500mm by 1200mm by 550mm, weighing more than 2.75 tons, such as automobile door inner panels and front grilles. The X, Y and Z axes (1300mm by 1000mm by 600mm, respectively) impart swift movements with rapid traverse rates of 58,000mm/min and cutting feedrates of 40,000mm/min. The A-axis of the V80S tilts at plus or minus 30 degrees, wide enough to machine holes for an angular pin, and the C-axis rotates at plus or minus 60 degrees, ensuring that the tool tip can be positioned to provide optimum contact with the workpiece. In addition, the machine is set with Makino’s Professional 6 (Pro6) control and Super Geometric Intelligence (SGI.5) software. Its slim, spindle nose design (only 165mm in diameter) offers greater accessibility and closer proximity to critical workpiece features with a wider variety of tools.
Greg Daco, chief U.S. Economist at Oxford Economics, and Laurie Harbour, president of Harbour Results, were keynote presenters at the event. Don Snow heard both speak and said, “Greg's perspective of the world's economics and our domestic challenges was a positive insight. Laurie shared information regarding the different size tool and die shops and what the future holds for them. Both presentations cause you to pause from the daily demands of riding the tool and die roller coaster and get a feel for the rest of the world and what the future challenges are going to be.”
Daco told attendees that the U.S.A., the EU and Japanese economies have gained momentum. China’s economy is still positive but is in “neutral mode” now. Japan’s GDP is growing at its fastest pace in two years, he says, but a key risk is the labor market and inflation. The country is expected to grow by 1.7 percent in 2018. Daco says China’s weaker real estate and exports are dampening growth and will experience ongoing gradual slow-down. While Mexico has shrugged off higher inflation, Daco says it’s a policy risk. Nonetheless, Mexico’s GDP is forecasted to see 2.2 percent growth in 2018. Canada, he says, is still seeing a lot of policy risk and uncertainty as well. In the Eurozone, he says a mini-boom is in the offing, particularly in Spain, which has experienced 3.2 percent growth annually since 2015. “So, the boom isn’t just in Germany,” Daco says, “The French and Italian economies are growing, too.” Forecasts show a more modest but healthy 2.2 percent growth in those countries. EU companies are making larger investments in capacity utilization and equipment, he says, but at the same time the Euro has strengthened, and that could hinder EU exports.
Both Daco and Harbour touched on the effects of political uncertainty on trade and economic growth. Daco says, “The U.S. economy will rebound after a slow start to the year. On average, we expect real GDP growth just above 2 percent in 2017, supported by a solid labor market, rising business investment and firmer global activity.” He also says he expects a fairly modest fiscal stimulus package will be approved next year.
Laurie Harbour agreed with Daco, saying the North American economy appears stable. She provided a view of the key trends impacting North American toolmakers in the coming years. She explained that because the majority of tool and die makers supply the automotive industry, that industry is prominent in her forecasting. That said, she told attendees the following:
- About 400 automotive models will be released by 2020, but in lower volumes than in previous retooling years.
- Big trucks, SUV’s and larger cars will be the thrust of the new programs between now and 2020. “More SUV’s means more tooling,” Harbour says.
- “If you’re a moldmaker who builds molds for automotive lighting, fascias, grilles, Class A surface metals, you will stay busy and steadily so.”
Like Daco, Harbour expects many mold and die shops to see continued growth over the next two or three years, “but headwinds are coming and companies should be prepared for that.” In the meantime, she says work on hold has fallen under 10 percent, which is good, and there is still a lot of steel sitting on Ford Motor Company’s shop floors, waiting to be awarded (in relation to the Ford Focus). A key trend with automakers such as Ford, GM and Chrysler is that they are looking to award big packages to a narrower field of Tier 1 suppliers and let them manage the overall programs. A key trend on the mold and die side is the lack of skilled labor, Harbour says, and it continues to be the foremost issue, followed by profitability and on-time delivery. She added that Canadian shops appear to be more concerned with political uncertainty regarding trade. Brian Bendig, president of Canada-based Cavalier Tool and Mfg. Ltd., told me, “We listened to the two analysts and I think now there is a healthy workload and work to be had. However, in a few short years this may look different and we (toolmakers) need to be prepared. Automation (labor reduction strategies) is going to be a big part of this, as well as the ability to work around the clock to drive down lead times.”
- Fit in Automation
Wes Stephens, account manager at Industrial Molds in Rockford, Illinois, was a guest speaker at Makino’s session on the benefits of automation. “At first, I didn’t understand how automation fit with building large, one-off molds,” he told the audience. “I thought of automation as something needed for companies making many repetitive parts, like a screw machine company, not molds. My view changed when I came to Industrial Molds. Our motivation for implementing automation was to reduce lead times. Automation was redefined as standardization, meaning the work is always held in the same fashion using a standard receiver like those Erowa makes. The system can have a fixture plate, V-block, or whatever is required to hold the workpiece to the standard receiver. This way the work can easily be installed into the machine the same way for cutting, and then removed for inspection. This also allows for another piece to be machined while the first is being inspected—even if one is a core and the other a cavity. The work has to fit into a certain space, which in our case is 12” x 12”, to fit into the carousel. This easy installation and removal of the work allows the offset to be established outside of the machine, since the Erowa is standard and the location can always be known. The work offset is incrementally so far in X and Y from the standard.”
Schools for mold polishing do not exist and most veteran polishers don't want to teach the subject, so here are a few simple polishing guidelines.
The correlation between the units of measure used to define mold surfaces is a commonly raised question. This article will lay these units of measure side by side in a conversion format so that companies can confidently understand with what they are dealing.
Mold cleaning is just one part of a systematic and comprehensive approach to mold maintenance. Here’s one moldmaker’s strategy for injection mold cleaning and an explanation of where and why different techniques are employed.