Founded in 1971, MSI Mold Builders (MSI; Cedar Rapids, Iowa and Greenville, South Carolina) designs and builds prototype and production plastic molds in steel and aluminum. These molds are used for injection, structural foam, blow, gas-assist and reaction-injection molding plus structural web processes. The ISO 9001:2008 certified company serves a diverse customer base in the computer/business equipment, consumer electronics, appliance, medical diagnostic, materials handling, sporting goods, lawn and garden, heavy equipment, aviation and commercial truck markets.
Lean, Leaner, Leanest
Since 2001, MSI has been committed to applying lean manufacturing, Six Sigma, and 5S principles to increase productivity, reduce waste, improve safety and ensure quality and customer satisfaction.
“As customers continue to demand shorter mold-delivery times and ask us to hold the line on costs, we have to find ways to continuously improve the speed and efficiency with which we make molds to maintain profitability,” explains Eric Kolsto, MSI director of technology and training. “Fortunately, we’ve seen dramatic quality and efficiency improvements since we started down the lean-manufacturing path. We’ve pushed moldmaking errors to nearly zero, allowing us to build higher-quality tools on very-aggressive delivery schedules that bring greater customer value.”
As a process-driven organization, the Cedar Rapids team sought efficiency improvements by continuously scrutinizing the company’s workflow — from order entry to shipping finished tools to the position of every machine on the facility’s 35,000-square-foot/3,252-square-meter shop floor. An important bottleneck was that every mold the company built had to pass through the facility’s single Tarus CNC gundrill.
“That machine was operating at 120-percent capacity with two shifts/day using it,” recalls Kolsto. “We gundrill all our air, water and oil lines, as well as our ejector pin ream and clearance holes. Once you get over 8 inches (20 centimeters) in aluminum and 4.5 to 6 inches (11-15 centimeters) in steel, it’s faster and more efficient to gundrill and you get better results.”
That meant the Tarus’ workload had increased significantly over the last decade as MSI shifted work from less-efficient to more-efficient processes. In turn, that led to bottlenecks, such as when big jobs held up other jobs on the gundrill. “We did a job a few years ago where a really big tool literally spent a month on the gundrill because the tool required so many cooling lines,” continues Kolsto. “We literally drilled a quarter-of-a-mile of holes in that mold.” Another nerve-wracking time came when the gundrill was down for six weeks and MSI had to farm drilling work out to toolmakers as far away as Milwaukee, Minneapolis, and Chicago because there are few toolmakers in their area that could or would take the work.
Switching to Deep-Tri tools was easy for MSI as no changes were needed to gundrill setup or coolant. In fact, the only change the team made was to drill faster at higher rpm.
“It’s times like that, when you’re trying to grow your business, you ask yourself if you shouldn’t buy another gundrill or move work to a less efficient process. However, before you make this type of change, you need to be disciplined enough to review how you’re using all your equipment and people.”
To that end, MSI conducted time studies to better understand how they were using their Tarus fitted with conventional brazed carbide tools. They looked at how many inches per minute they could drill with each tool before it had to be sharpened or replaced, what rpm they were running at, and how long tool changes took. They even monitored spindle loads. That provided a performance baseline. The study showed that 80 percent of what they were drilling was P20 steel with 9/16-inches (0.563 inches/14.3 millimeter) diameter holes.
Evaluations Bring Improvements
Because of MSI’s size and reputation, suppliers frequently drop by to introduce new technologies and leave samples for the team to try. That was the case several years ago when three different tooling suppliers offered three different types of gundrill tools that the team ran through the same kinds of time studies to see what improvements each offered.
The first supplier brought in first-generation indexable tools that didn’t need to be sharpened. Instead, as a tool face dulled, you just indexed the insert and turned a new edge forward. Where before MSI was drilling 0.9-inches/23-millimeters per minute with conventional brazed tips, with the indexable tools they drilled 4.0 inches/102 millimeters per minute. Although there’s no data on how often they changed traditional brazed drills, with the indexable inserts, MSI could drill 150 linear inches/381 lineal centimeters before needing to index another edge forward.
Another supplier brought the team a second-generation solid brazed tip with a proprietary grind. With this product, MSI drilled at 4.0-7.0 inches/102-178 millimeters per minute and could go 65-1,500 lineal inches/165-3,810 lineal centimeters — with an average value was 350 lineal inch/889 lineal centimeters — before the drills dulled. Unfortunately, since this product couldn’t be resharpened, when it did dull, it had to be tossed and it could take months to receive replacements if MSI’s and its tool supplier’s stocks ran low.
A third supplier offered a second-generation indexable drill. This technology enabled MSI to drill 10.1 inches/257 millimeters per minute – a order of magnitude improvement. Additionally, the team could drill 350 lineal inches/889 lineal centimeters per insert edge x 3 rotations (edges)/insert for 1,050 linear inches/2,667 lineal centimeters before needing to replace the insert.
The product that made such a difference to MSI’s productivity was Deep-Tri drill tools produced by Tungaloy Corp. (Fukushima, Japan) and sold by Tungaloy America, Inc. (Arlington Heights, Illinois). Interestingly, this product’s heritage draws from two different industries. The first is gundrilling from metalworking. The second is single-tube-system (STS) drilling (also called BTA drilling after the now-defunct Boring and Trepanning Association) for deep-hole machining used in aerospace and oil and gas exploration.
Introduced in 2015, Tungaloy’s product features a drill body that stays in the machine. As one edge of the carbide insert and guide paths begins to dull, it takes less than a minute to index each to a new edge. Each insert is a pure carbide cutting surface carefully honed at just the right angles to produce a sharp, long-lasting edge. Unique to Deep-Tri inserts is a chip-splitter feature. Serrated “teeth” on the cutting edge break up chips into much smaller pieces so they’re easier to evacuate, potentially allowing less coolant and lower coolant pressures to be used while drilling at higher rpm. The tool also features two or more pairs of guide pads, which help stabilize the tool so cutting forces stay balanced and holes remain consistently straight as the drill pushes deeper into the work piece — particularly when it intersects cross-holes. Guide pads also improve hole finish.
Several types of inserts are available depending on drill diameter. The most common model is triangular with three cutting edges and three serrated teeth per edge. It fits tools from 14-28 millimeters/0.55-1.1 inches in diameter. A two-sided insert with two edges and two chip splitters per edge fits smaller diameter tools from 12-14 millimeters/0.47-0.55 inches. For tools greater than 28 millimeters/1.1 inches in diameter, parallelogram-shaped inserts are used. Three parallelogram inserts are used in tandem to accomplish the same functionality as serrated teeth on smaller inserts.
The company reports that versus conventional brazed tips, gundrill feeds and speeds typically increase by a factor of 3.5-4. “Not only can you drill faster, but you can drill better because smaller chips don’t scratch the hole, so hole finish is excellent.”
“Our concept with the Deep-Tri drill was to make it indexable with inserts and guide pads, so there was no need to change the whole body when an edge dulled,” explains Kedar Bhagath, Tungaloy America chief technical officer. “Now tool changes take less than a minute because all you need to do is index the insert by rotating a new edge forward instead of taking a brazed gundrill out of its machine through the whip guides. That eliminates downtime and saves money. And since the biggest challenge with drilling holes is scarf evacuation, the ability of our chip splitters to break chips up into smaller pieces that are easier to flush out means you can drill much faster.” The company reports that versus conventional brazed tips, gundrill feeds and speeds typically increase by a factor of 3.5-4. “Not only can you drill faster, but you can drill better because smaller chips don’t scratch the hole, so hole finish is excellent,” he adds.
Insert design is said to be critical as is the honing on the cutting edge. “To the naked eye, it looks simple, but the small rounding and rake angles play a huge role in the improving machining efficiency,” explains Bhagath.
Switching to Deep-Tri tools was easy for MSI as no changes were needed to gundrill setup or coolant. In fact, the only change the team made was to drill faster at higher rpm. “The productivity gains we saw represented a very serious improvement that really revolutionized our business,” continues Kolsto. His team loves the product and only wishes the tools were available in smaller sizes so MSI could do more of its gundrilling with the technology.
Bhagath adds that not only are mold and die shops making the change, but Deep-Tri drills are now being used to drill deeper holes using lathes and other machining centers. “The hole straightness and diameter tolerances achieved are so precise with this technology that it has opened up new applications and new ways to drill deeper holes for many of these shops,” he adds.
MSI Mold Builders
Tungaloy America Inc.
While both hot runner and cold runner systems have their benefits, for design flexibility as well as reduced cycle times and costs, hot runner systems will probably be the better choice.
To achieve the ultimate capability and level of productivity from your wire EDM on a consistent, repeatable and reliable basis, regular maintenance is a required task.
Prototyping helps evaluate and test a design, clarify production costs, sell a product and secure patents.