Cutter Sets New Standard for Heavy Hogging
The Gold-QuadF in action at Nova Tool and Mold.
“The chips came off so big and heavy, it took a shovel to clear them. They came off so fast, we had to buy bigger bins. Unbelievable!”
So says John Novosel Jr., president of Nova Tool and Mold, about the company’s recent success with machining a large mold core on a 75-hp vertical mill. Yet, it wasn’t so much the 64 cubic inch per minute metal removal rate (MRR) that impressed Novasel and other witnesses. Rather, it was the fact that such a large face mill could achieve this rate in such demanding conditions. The application required not just facing, but also contouring, all with extensions as long as 14 inches.
Celebrating its 25th anniversary this year, Nova Tool and Mold has plenty of experience with hogging large mold blocks. The 30-man, Windsor, Ontario, shop runs 16/5, mainly providing medium and large injection molds for automotive and other industries. Previously, go-to cutters for rough facing and contouring applications like the one described above were 2- and 4-inch Ingersoll Gold-Quad F face mills. These tools ran on 8-inch extensions at 120 ipm and stepovers exceeding 75 percent of cutter diameter. Under these long-reach conditions, running any faster raised the risk of chatter and premature insert failure.
The company had considered bigger face mills of the same style in the past, but doubted whether they could handle contouring as well as facing, especially on the long reaches. Management couldn’t justify spending $1,000 for a cutter body that could do face milling only.
This thinking changed in January, when an order came in for a mold to produce a large, front-end panel for a truck body in a single shot on a 3,000-ton molding machine. The P20, Rc-28 block was huge, measuring 77 by 50 by 32 inches and weighing in at 17.5 tons. The mold’s active area measured 77 by 24 by 32 inches. Roughing operations alone would remove 6 tons of stock and require 14-inch extensions to create the full profile. “The size of the core gave us reason to rethink our attitude about the supposed ‘limitations’ of large-diameter face mills,” says John Barsotta, plant manager. “If it worked, we’d save 16 hours of heavy roughing.”
Gary Martinello of distributor Keyline Cutting Tools, which had been supplying Nova Tool with the smaller Gold-Quad F cutters for years, agreed that a bigger tool was worth a try. The mold was simply too big and the potential savings too great. In addition, he says the 6-inch version of the tool had already demonstrated a good track record for both facing and contouring in dozens of other shops, even on extensions. Introduced less than two years ago for high-feed rough facing, profiling and interrupted-cut applications, the tool features extra-thick inserts and strong, oversized clamping screws for security during deeper, aggressive cuts. According the manufacturer, free-cutting geometry further reduces cutting forces, while a proprietary post-coating technology smooths the surface and strengthens the bond between coating and substrate.
Extreme MRR, Stable Operation
Barsotta and Martinello worked with Ingersoll’s Bill Fiorenza, project manager for die and mold tools, to set the parameters. The machine selected for the job was a reconditioned Rambaudi vertical mill with a 75-hp spindle and updated controls. Based on available power and speed, Fiorenza recommended roughing the P20 in the wrought condition at 100 ipm, 250 rpm and a 0.1-inch cutting depth with a 5-inch stepover, then backing off slightly on all parameters for hardened stock. Barsotta, Martinello and Ingersoll field rep Paul Poirier ran trials to work up to those settings, and it was thumbs-up, even on an 8-inch extension. “We were removing over 50 cubes a minute and getting decent edge life,” Barsotta says. “And it ran quiet—no chatter. It was a stable operation despite the extreme removal rates.”
Fiorenza adds that this was one of the highest MRRs the cutting tool supplier has seen under these machining conditions. Nonetheless, Nova Tool has pushed the envelope a little further since the first job. Standard feed rate is now 120 ipm. Stepover has also increased from 5 to 5 3/8 inches (said to be high for a 6-inch cutter), and neither edge life nor stability has suffered. In fact, Fiorenza says that the 6-inch Gold-Quad F has performed successfully even with fully engaged, 6-inch cuts in solid steel.
That’s not to suggest it took a great deal of additional testing to convince Nova Tool to standardize on the larger tool for all mold blocks ranging from 24 by 24 inches to 4 by 6 feet. Barsotta still remembers being taken aback by the number of chips and what it took to extract them during the first trial runs. “The chips were as big as my thumb—3½ inches long and ½ inch wide,” he recalls. “They were too heavy to just blow off, and they came off so fast that we ran out of chip bins.
Perhaps even more surprising was the stability of the operation, even with 14-inch extensions. Cutting edges lasted at least 2 hours in the cut, and inserts were indexed due to flank wear only, never rupture. “It was actually more stable than running the smaller cutters on those extensions,” he says. “We can live with surprises like these.”
While both hot runner and cold runner systems have their benefits, for design flexibility as well as reduced cycle times and costs, hot runner systems will probably be the better choice.
While EDM speeds today are impressive, there are a number of machining variables that influence the machining speed of the wire EDM.
High-feed milling can significantly outweigh potential reliability challenges. Consider these six strategies in order to make high-feed milling successful for your business.